Falling stocks reflect reality- for a change...
"Our blunders mostly come from letting our wishes interpret our duties"
~Author Unknown
Stock market's behavior of last 10 days or so has been a complete puzzle to me. It seems like with all the "technical" indicators and experts out there pointing towards an impending market crash and absolute collapse of the US Economy, fear has been making a slow but steady comeback into investor's minds and in my book it's a positive sign, but we by no means "all long" territory yet...
I think as it's becoming evident every day, what was initially perceived to be a short housing sector led recession/slowdown, is now quickly converging into a full blown capitulation of anything that could be vaguely defined as consumer discretionary. Last week a multitude of stocks in sectors most sensitive to the prolonged slowdown have established new lows- casinos, autos, lodging, recreational vehicles, regional banks, airlines, old media (newspapers and TV), construction, retailers. The list could gets long very quickly...
Even the formerly bullet proof oil and gas, materials and agricultural darlings have posted double digit declines in the last several days with more declines on the horizon... What is even more troubling- the VIX volatility index is still only trading at around 26, far away from the 30+ capitulation level reached twice earlier this year...
Why is it important? Let's step back for a second- what happened during the last few capitulation days- back in August 2007, January and March 2008? Every time when it seemed like things were almost slipping into the "sell everything and forget the stock market forever territory", Federal Reserve stepped and bailed investors out with the rate cuts. They first cut the discount rate in August in response to the "quant" hedge fund fiasco. More rate cuts followed again in a response to the worldwide stock market collapse that now seems to have been triggered by a rogue trader in Society General, and finally- one more emergency "super cut" was presented in response to Bear Sterns fiasco. "Liquidity magic" worked like a charm every time- indices pulled off spectacular rallies and recovered above the previous lows...
But now we come to today's situation. Fed is now clearly worried about rising inflation expectation and thus no more "savior" rate cuts could be expected. My guess is that we'll see more reactive actions from the government in the form of new stimulus checks, possible bailouts and infrastructure investments, but all of these rescues take time to pass and thus won't be a quick band-aid if things get really rough out there for a day or two.
One can certainly argue that we might have seen the lows for the year- as stock prices now have approached levels not since late 2005. I've also read many different experts saying that VIX is no longer a good "indicator of fear" because of lower holiday volumes, summer vacations etc... But I am personally afraid that the "talking heads" are likely to be wrong again- I think VIX is low simply because this time the declines of the major indices are not disorderly or unexpected... They are completely reasonable and based on the actual economic picture- markets have been simply getting better in pricing the actual dire economic situation into the stock prices. The excess liquidity generated by the silly actions of Federal Reserve washed up in the most logical but very unwelcome place- basic materials, oil and gas and other commodities, which in turn made the already unhealthy economic situation much worse...
Now, any company that is heavily reliant on the US consumers driving, dining out or buying the next new "ipod", "iphone" or "blackberry" is feeling the pinch. Finding good stocks to "short" has actually been easier lately than finding good "long" ideas. If the company provides a service or sells a product that could be considered as vaguely discretionary, and also has a lot of debt, negative cash flows and might need refinancing in the next 6-12 months, it spells TROUBLE...Think GM and Ford, or pretty much any of the indebted automotive suppliers, RV manufactures or casinos and/or lodging companies that could not make money even when the economy was much stronger... Plus the usual safe heavens in the form of emerging markets are no longer bullet-proof. With Fed outsourcing its rate tightening job to other central banks around the world- the whole world economy is rapidly slowing down...
In addition to that- I am now growing a bit more skeptical whether we will see the usual "earnings pop". It certainly doesn't seem that we had much success so far- FDX, NKE and RIMM come to mind for now. We'll see if AA and GE do any better this week- but for now simply try to stay safe...
Please feel free to e-mail me your questions at skepticalcapitalist@gmail.com
















